Interbrand Design Forum Ranks the Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands; Walmart is Top Retailer, Followed by Best Buy and Home Depot
Report Indicates Importance of Brand for Driving Sales in a Downturn Economy
January 13, 2009 - DAYTON, OHIO, US - Interbrand Design Forum, the world’s largest retail brand consultants, today released the Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands, the first-ever ranking of the top 50 American retail brands. Walmart claimed top honors as the most valuable retail brand in 2008, followed by popular retailers Best Buy (No. 2), The Home Depot (No. 3), Target (No.4) and CVS (No. 5).
Following the deflated earnings of the 2008 holiday shopping season, it is apparent that shoppers have changed their behavior in response to a downturn economy. With brand accounting for 25 percent of the decision to shop at a particular store, the top retailers understand the emphasis that is now needed on brand. As a result, the trend toward large, pervasive and impersonal retail spaces is reversing in favor of stores with more emotion, creativity and community.
“In a recession, brand is more important than ever, as retailers with a well-positioned brand have the opportunity to thrive and seize a bigger piece of the pie in terms of customers,” said Lee Carpenter, chief executive officer of Interbrand Design Forum. “Retailers are now realizing that brand transcends its traditional marketing role and should be adopted as an idea that runs through every part of the company. During a period of increased competition and lowered sales, brands that have successful propositions, such as Walmart, and offer an engaging shopping experience, like Best Buy, will come out on top.”
Walmart was recognized as the top American retail brand in 2008 after being plagued by years of negative perceptions about the company. As America’s largest retailer, Walmart evolved into a brand and differentiated itself from other discount retailers by understanding its consumer base and carving out a niche for value-driven shoppers. With a brand value of $129 billion, Walmart is the most valuable retail brand in the world.
Several non-traditional retailers, such as those with an online-only presence, were included in the ranking, including Dell Company (No. 6), eBay (No. 11), Amazon.com (No. 14) and Netflix (No. 32). Out of the top 50 companies included in the Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands, only six do not have online channels. Amazon, which attracts over 50 million visitors a month, offers customized service for its simple transactions from start-to-finish, specialized for every person who visits the site.
Specialization enables retailers to make strong emotional connections with consumers by offering a more meaningful shopping experience, which in-turn, helps to create future earnings by building relationships with customers. Brands that excel at specialization include AutoZone (No. 25), Dick’s Sporting Goods (No. 38), American Girl (No. 41) and Barnes and Noble (No. 44).
“Even in a downturn economy, consumers will always need a reason to purchase goods,” said Carpenter. “Offering a shopping experience that delivers on the brand proposition can be the ultimate factor that drives shoppers into your store and can serve as the catalyst of a potential long-term relationship with a loyal consumer.”
In terms of department stores, financial woes kept iconic brands such as Macy’s, Saks Fifth Avenue and Sears off the list, while Nordstrom (No. 13), Kohl’s (No. 22) and JCPenny (No. 24) all ranked high. JCPenny’s success can be attributed to five billion-dollar private brands catering to the middle-American shopper, who seek both variety and value.
Grocery stores, including Kroger, Safeway and Supervalu, were all but absent from the ranking of the top retailers, as the grocery sector scored low in terms of customer loyalty and brand strength. Supermarkets depend heavily on promotions and pushing product out of the stores, rather than focusing on the experience of the customer or product differentiation. However, Whole Foods Market made it into the top 50 list (No. 47), and is perceived to provide the highest quality food offering in the industry. By placing a cap on the number of stores in operation to less than 300 and supporting entrepreneurial manufacturers, Whole Foods delivers on its promise of an unmatched variety of organic and natural foods.
“Successful brands bend and curve with the changing economy and continue to engage and deliver a unique experience to the consumer. The retailers included in our ranking are constantly evolving and optimizing their brand strategies based on the current environment, and this renewed focus on brand is what will carry these companies through the volatile times ahead,” added Carpenter.
The results will also be discussed at the National Retail Federation 98th Annual Convention & EXPO on January 14, 2009 in New York City.
The Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands 2009
Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands 2009 Methodology and Results
To qualify for inclusion in the Interbrand Design Forum Most Valuable U.S. Retail Brands, each company must be a market-facing brand with publicly available financial data and positive Economic Value Added. The Interbrand method for valuing examines brands through the lens of financial strength, importance in driving consumer selection and the likelihood of ongoing branded revenue. This methodology evaluates brand value in the same way any other corporate asset is valued—on the basis of how much it is likely to earn for the company in the future.
About Interbrand Design Forum
Since 1978, we have been creating retail brand experiences for companies around the world. Interbrand Design Forum’s talent for game-changing innovation led us to create a business model that integrates analytics-based strategy—the first and only company with such a comprehensive offering.
This unique ability to address retail’s growing complexity led many of the world’s top companies to our doorstep and propelled Interbrand Design Forum to the forefront of the industry.
In 2008, we added Interbrand to our Design Forum name to reflect our place in the world’s largest branding consultancy; we have been part of Interbrand since 2002.
Interbrand began to work with brands in 1974, when the world still thought of “brand” as just another word for “logo.” Today, we have 1,200 associates in almost 40 offices around the globe and a practice that brings together a diverse team of insightful right- and left-brain thinkers. This deep talent pool makes our business both rigorously analytic and highly creative.
As a result, we have changed the dialogue, defined the meaning of brand management, and continue to lead the debate around brand as a valuable business asset. By making brand central to our clients’ strategic business goals, we help them create, manage and grow the value of their brands.